Our Team



Know what Geno does after a long shift in the shop serving breakfast and lunch? He goes home and cooks dinner. His dedication to the craft is unrivaled and his passion for finding the best ingredients and flavor combinations has made our breakfast sandwiches the most sought-after on the island.


Head Barista

You’d think if your job was coffee, you’d find something else to do a as hobby, but whether it’s coffee-flavored chocolates or tequila, Alena is always thinking about the beans. As our resident expert, Alena is personally responsible for designing the roasts, blends and specialty brews you enjoy in our shop.

Our Mission

Before settling in Key West, Keys Coffee Co. owner Geno spent the better part of a decade cooking in some of the East Coast’s best restaurants, from 410 Bank Street in Cape May to a few of the most popular destinations in the Florida Keys. After spending seven years in the kitchens of Key West, he and his wife Alena — who is a coffee connoisseur and spent years working as a barista — felt that the Florida Keys were in need of a restaurant that served the highest quality coffees with fresh, delicious food.
Keys Coffee Co. is a product of their years of experience in restaurants and cafés, bringing only the best to their own operation. They are committed to serving locally roasted beans and handcrafted breakfast and lunch sandwiches with the best available local ingredients. All eggs are cooked to order, and all spreads and sauces are made in-house. The majority of their baked goods are made on-site, but they also source from some of the best local purveyors, like Goldman’s Deli.

The fresh ingredients and commitment to local products can be tasted in every bite.

Their attention to detail is evidenced by things like taking the time to prepare coffee ice cubes to make sure your cold coffee is never watered down, or the crispiness that comes from making their conch fritters in-house. And their knowledge of the product they serve is extensive: you can ask where your coffee came from or find out what particular aromas and flavors are associated with your brew.
As a local, family-owned business, they’re proud to take the time to both provide exceptional customer service and produce a superior product.
Geno and Alena invite you to drop in to Keys Coffee Co. and try what locals are happy to call The Best Coffee in Key West.

Our Beans


Origin: Colombia
Roast: Medium/Dark

Notes: Fairly sweet, with hints of fruit & cocoa

Origin: Colombia
Roast: Medium

Notes: Creamy texture with a hint of smooth rum flavor

Origin: House Secret
Roast: Medium/Light

Notes: Cold brew for smooth and light nuttiness

Origin: Colombia
Roast: Medium

Notes: Mild notes of raspberry and chocolate

Origin: Colombia
Roast: Dark

Notes: Potent nutty aroma with a rich chocolatey finish

Origin: Colombia
Roast: Medium

Notes: Clearly this one tastes like hazelnut.